Murder conviction overturned thanks to Cardiff law college students

The victim of a miscarriage of justice has praised the students who investigated his situation, after a historic ruling saw his murder conviction overturned on appeal thanks to the work of a team lead by Cardiff University.

Dwaine George, now aged 30, was jailed for daily life in 2002 for the shooting of 18-12 months-previous Daniel Dale in Manchester, and served twelve many years behind bars on a life sentence before being freed final 12 months. But on Tuesday best judges overturned his conviction, and praised the “diligent” perform of law college students who helped provide the evidence which they deemed produced the conviction “no longer safe”.

George, who has often maintained his innocence, was helped by law college students at Cardiff University operating underneath the university’s Innocence Venture, which investigates potential miscarriages of justice. Quashing his conviction these days, one particular of the most senior judges in the nation Sir Brian Leveson, explained the it was “no longer safe” and praised “the work of the Innocence Project and Professional Bono Unit at Cardiff Law School, which took up the appellant’s situation and pursued it so diligently”. George has usually denied currently being involved with the 2001 killing of Dale, who was gunned down in Manchester days before he had been due to give proof at Manchester crown court about the killing of his ideal buddy. Paul Ward, 16, had been stabbed to death in a street attack in the city earlier in the year.

The prosecution argued that George – who denied all involvement – and one more man, Ryan Brown, had utilised a Walther PPK self-loading pistol to destroy Dale. They presented proof of a really modest quantity of gunshot residue located on a black Henri Lloyd hooded jacket discovered below the stairs at George’s property.

George’s very first appeal failed in 2004, but the Criminal Circumstances Assessment Commission (CCRC) referred the murder conviction to the court of appeal for a 2nd time. The current appeal focused on new guidelines which cast doubt on making use of tiny particles of gunshot residue as evidence. Students contacted Dennis McGuire, a US-primarily based gunshot residue specialist, who offered the basis for the students’ technical submissions. In his judgment, produced with Mr Justice Green and Mr Justice Goss, Leveson pointed to new suggestions on firearms residue issued by the Forensic Science Services (FSS) in 2006, two many years after George’s conviction. If the new recommendations had been followed “the number and sort of particles of residue discovered on the coat were so little so as to be at or near the degree at which they could not be considered to have evidential worth,” in accordance to the judgment. If the judge at the unique trial had access to the new tips his directions to the jury “would have been couched in terms of a lot greater circumspection and caution,” it extra.

In a statement George thanked students, professors and professional-bono lawyers for securing the overturning of his conviction, “First and foremost, my thoughts go out to Daniel Dale’s family. He lost his existence in this tragic event and I often explained I wasn’t accountable for that,” he said. “Today I have acquired the outcome I wanted – I have lost a whole lot of my daily life that I can not get back, but I just want to get on with my daily life now. I hope the Cardiff Innocence Venture will get all the recognition it deserves for this. I want to thank all these who assisted me – the students and staff at Cardiff, my solicitor David McCorkle, James Wood QC and Tunde Okewale from Doughty Street Chambers”.

Thirty present and former college students of Cardiff attended George’s appeal on six November to witness the students’ investigative perform presented by barristers to a panel of appeal court judges. The university is one particular of a amount of higher education institutions that operate on circumstances of possible miscarriages of justice. Prof Julie Cost, who runs the Cardiff task with Dr Dennis Eady, said university college students had worked for “hundreds of hours” on the situation more than a 4 year time period and the fact that it was the first situation to be overturned with the help of an innocence project in nine many years exposed critical flaws in the appeal method. But she said she was not “pleased” at the end result. “We hope this situation will draw focus to the genuine problems with the appeal task, but are extremely conscious that a young guy was killed and his loved ones will have to go by means of more suffering and that has to dominate our thoughts,” she explained.

George’s barrister James Wood QC explained: “The operate of the Innocence Undertaking of Cardiff University basically contributed magnificently in the direction of overturning this abiding miscarriage of justice. Dwaine George had been convicted upon flawed voice identification proof, and flawed microscopically minuscule gunshot residue on an item of clothing seized from his cellar, which science now discloses could not bear the burden of his conviction. Dwaine protested his innocence all through his long imprisonment and obtained a degree while incarcerated. He can now seek to put his existence with each other once again as an innocent guy wholly vindicated by this judgment.”

Dale’s mother explained she had been left “feeling sick” at the choice to quash George’s conviction. “There is no appeal obtainable for my son’s life,” Lynn Hayes advised the Manchester Evening News. “No volume of time will ever fix the heartbreak that my family members continue to endure every single and every day.”

Leave a Reply