The Learning Network: What Are Your Opinions on Cosmetic Surgery?

Photograph
Renée Zellweger, left, in “Case 39,” which was shot in 2009. Final week, Ms. Zellweger unveiled a new seem, proper, at Elle magazine’s annual Females in Hollywood celebration. Relevant Write-upCredit score Mario Anzuoni/Reuters (proper)

Last week, right after a “radically diverse looking” Renée Zellweger attended an awards ceremony, a lot of speculated that she had had plastic surgical procedure, even though Ms. Zellweger denied it.

What are your ideas about cosmetic surgical treatment in common and about the flood of information stories and reactions to Ms. Zellweger? Why do you consider people seemed to care so considerably about how her encounter seems to be?

In the Area for Debate forum, a number of writers consider on “Renée Zellweger and the Query of Aging .”

Troy Alexander writes:

Visual appeal is the gateway to one’s personalized brand — it is the very first point a person sees, and correct or wrong, 1 of the 1st items we judge (and are judged on). Just as we develop and alter in our romantic partnerships, our family and our profession, so too need to we evolve inside that personal fashion as we age. Whether Renée Zellweger has had plastic surgical procedure is none of our enterprise it is her brand and she can do with it what she desires.

But there is a larger situation here. As a society we need to have to worth women as they age, and not push them to feel that they have to go underneath the knife to search younger. And at the identical time, we have to stop criticizing those very same ladies for carrying out just what we have pressured them to do. It is up to every single of us to embrace the modifications that come with time or do anything about them. That is in which the magic lies — in getting O.K. with who we decide on to be.

Cindy Joseph writes:

Plastic surgical procedure is simply a symptom. Ageism in our nation, exclusively against ladies, has gone also far.

…Women are judged on their looks and then advised their “looks” fade in excess of time, which leads them to feel they will be significantly less valued as they age. No wonder girls spend billions of bucks every single year on Botox, wrinkle lotions and cosmetic surgical treatment to stave off the indications of life as time moves on.

Students: Study the complete Room for Debate forum, then tell us…

–Did you adhere to the information about Renée Zellweger? What did you make of it? Do you care if she had plastic surgical procedure or not?

–What is your opinion on cosmetic surgical treatment in general? When, if ever, do you think it is O.K. to have it? Or, do you agree with Troy Alexander that your face is your “personal brand” to do with what ever you like?

–Do you agree with Cindy Joseph that plastic surgical treatment is basically a “symptom” of sexism and ageism in the United States, and that females are judged far too significantly on their appears? How else do you see this?

–Do you feel you might have cosmetic surgical treatment at some level in your life? Why or why not?

–What arguments can you make for cosmetic surgical treatment? What arguments can you make against it?


College students 13 and older are invited to comment beneath. Please use only your very first name. For privacy policy reasons, we will not publish student feedback that incorporate a final identify.

Leave a Reply