Why we have to raise the bar to turning out to be a barrister

I was referred to as to the bar in July and like numerous other people, I was left disappointed and angry by the top quality of the bar professional training program (BPTC), which college students must comprehensive prior to beginning pupillage, to go on to qualify as a practising barrister.

Although pupillage is very aggressive, the BPTC remains effortless to get on to – basically, you need to have a two:two and a good deal of money.

I was a student representative at my law school and every single meeting centered on the low academic and linguistic level of many students who shouldn’t have been there.

In several adversarial advocacy exercise routines, my opponents had no grasp of the appropriate law, and hence couldn’t place forward arguments to counter mine. A massive portion of marks are allotted awarding for rebutting arguments, so this failure was of true consequence to me.

It may possibly sound harsh, but when an individual is contemplating investing around £17,500 – in London – and competing with thousands for all around 430 pupillage spots, realism is required.

How do I know many college students are not great enough? In 2013, just 56.2% of students passed the notoriously challenging civil litigation examination, which you have to get via to pass the program.

Lady Ruth Deech, chair of the Bar Standards Board (BSB), which sets the program, acknowledged the dilemma in February 2011, saying: “There are too numerous individuals on the program who shouldn’t be there. We need to have to give a signal to individuals who aren’t up to it that they’re wasting their cash.”

That the regulator which sets the course is conscious of the issue but has done absolutely nothing, except introduce an aptitude test, is galling.

The Bar Course Aptitude Test (BCAT), introduced for the 2013 consumption, would seem to have had no impact. But the BSB says it requirements two years’ worth of information to assess its effectiveness.

A BSB spokesperson says: “The BCAT will have had a considerable effect in deterring some aspiring candidates – who would not have been capable to total the BPTC – from applying in the 1st spot, but of program this is really difficult to measure.”

Kaplan’s brief-lived BPTC, which was discontinued in September, set the bar. To get in you had to have an interview, comprehensive a written exercise and complete some advocacy. This ensured that they only took these who stood a likelihood of acquiring pupillage.

It also meant students were surrounded by other intelligent and motivated students functioning in direction of the very same aim. Kaplan went beyond the BSB’s minimum requirements (pdf), resulting in a pupillage success charge far higher than regular.

Sadly, no other provider has this kind of rigid entry needs, though the University of Law has adopted them for up coming year’s intake.

A failure to interview means a greater danger of language issues. Several international students do the BPTC – 75% non-EU college students at the University of West England in 2013, for illustration – and there have been complaints of insufficient ranges of English.

A spokesperson at BPP University, a BPTC supplier, says: “Entry demands for the BPTC are set by the BSB and not individual suppliers.

“BPP exams and supports all global college students to guarantee they meet ideal requirements of English.”

BPP might adhere to the BSB’s minimum standards, but BSB reviews of the university have raised factors comparable to those I’m generating right here. Over-recruitment and English language monitoring have been regarded problematic this yr, for example (pdf).

A spokesperson for the BSB says they are mindful from meetings and surveys that some college students are concerned about their peers’ English language proficiency, but they think the minimal entry specifications are sufficiently demanding.

“These include that college students are fluent in English, regardless of their 1st language, and can demonstrate this by obtaining set scores in both the Pearson Test of English or the Worldwide English Language Testing Technique check,” says the spokesperson.

“It’s up to companies to check and create whether a student’s English language abilities are satisfactory just before accepting them onto the program. Suppliers are also essential to eliminate college students from the BPTC programme if it gets apparent that the pupil is unable to demonstrate a proficient level of English.”

The BSB sets out distinct troubles in monitoring reports on its website, but why is not much more completed to tackle them?

The BSB spokesperson says: “Our reviews set out suggestions for suppliers to address any concerns that may possibly have arisen in the course of these visits. There are situations in which action has been essential, and these are documented in our reports.”

As the physique behind the BPTC, the BSB sets minimum specifications, but who will consider obligation for raising the demands and restoring integrity to the program?

From my experience, carrying out pair-based mostly advocacy function with somebody who is not totally fluent in English is aggravating.

It is also problematic functioning with men and women who aren’t academically sturdy sufficient. In 2012, 40% of folks at Birmingham’s University of Law had a 2:2. This merely does not reflect the specifications set by pupillage applications – only 4.one% of profitable pupillage applicants had a 2:two in 2011.

The end result? If you get caught with the incorrect men and women, the value of a lesson plummets. That hurts when you are paying so considerably money.

Contemplate medication. It is difficult to get into healthcare school – you have to interview and have a critically very good application. Upon completion, you stand a robust chance of functioning as a physician afterwards. There is, in effect, a bottleneck at the start of the procedure.

Exactly where is the bottleneck in barrister land? Pupillage. With lower entry needs for the BPTC, 1000’s pass the course every year. The BPTC is of restricted use without having pupillage – at most you are a “barrister at law”, dependant on pupillage to qualify.

So what’s my level? First of all, the minimal entry requirements undermine the value of the course and fail to bring the very best out of prospective barristers.

Secondly, it commences to appear like profiteering when below par college students are permitted onto the program. Each and every chamber’s pupillage part on their web site demands a two:one, or an exceptional cause why someone has a 2:2.

BPTC suppliers should adopt this yardstick, at least. Interviews must be necessary, not only to make certain competence and a ample level of English, but to assess drive and motivation.

I felt virtually specific when I acquired my location on the BPTC, expecting a program filled with intellectuals who had been aspiring to perform in one particular of the toughest and most aggressive markets in the country.

But I quickly realised that there was nothing at all prestigious about the course, save for the call to the bar ceremony for these who managed to pass.

Leave a Reply